Watched the four part documentary "Teardrop Nation" by Sarah Kabir. Having been pressed by a good friend of mine not miss it, I took the advice and watched all four episodes over a fortnight. It is needed to be said that pre-2009, I had taken a great interest in the events which led to our civil war, and as such had occasion to read somewhat extensively on the areas which are captured here under "The Seeds We Sow". While what has been captured here is incontestable, in hindsight how both segments of the racial divide interpreted these events can never be agreed upon. For example, "The Broken Palmyra" distinguishes between discriminatory admissions and affirmative action for the disadvantaged in University admissions, observing that “Many Tamils would have agreed to the modification of the principle of pure merit by means of non-racial criteria to help the underprivileged", as the racial quota has left a bad taste in their mouths. On the other side of the racial divide the Sinhalese would continue to harp on the advantage the Tamils had received at the hands of the British, especially in terms of education. Yet, the British had previously rejected the ask for a 50-50 demand by the G.G. Ponnambalam with the central objection being that giving roughly one-third of the population half the seats would distort representative government by disproportionately weighting minority votes. The commission’s position is reported as refusing to create an “artificial majority out of a minority.” So in essence the seeds that were sowed were those of mistrust, and it continued to grow.*
Part two, is closer to home as the 1983 riots are lived in experiences for us, albeit as a kid of eight years. While this episode details such pivotal incidents such as the Vadukkodai resolution, the 1977 anti-Tamil riots, the burning of the Jaffna library, as well as mentioning the many bomb blasts that the LTTE were responsible for., 1983 pogroms is treated with the gravity it deserves. Interviews were carried out by many former politicians, and political commentators. However the single interview that was such a disappointment, and gave rise to a feeling of anger in me, was that of Ranil Wickramasinghe, former president, for his impertinence and the remorselessness in which he recounted the events of 1983. Two other interviews that caught my attention was that of Victor Ivan, and Ferial Ashraff, widow of politician M.H.M. Ashraff. Ivan went on record to say that if the JVP had captured power in 1971, they would've found themselves wanting in how to manage the affairs of the state. It brought upon a smile to me, given how they are managing the affairs of the state 55 years later too, now that they are finally in power. Ferial Ashraff clearly says that her husband believed in Eelam, and is supposed to have said he stood for Eelam, even if then TULF leader Amirthalingam gave up on it. Although I have heard that being mentioned in various news paper articles by third parties in the 90s, it being mentioned by his wife, proved the conviction that was in Ashraff.
Part Three starts round about the time of CBK's second tenure as president. CBK in particular is presented in better light compared to other leaders, citing that her efforts at peace were largely genuine compared to others. So much so, it is at this point, especially during the short stint when Ranil Wickramasinghe was the prime minister that LTTE first experienced a split, with the break away of the Karuna fraction. Karuna is given much focus, where his views are expressed, and he claims that while he wanted a political settlement of sorts, Prabhakaran was never comfortable with this. The fact there were efforts at a negotiated settlement through talks, and Karuna supposedly was influenced by it is on record here.
War in paradise, part IV, covers the third and fourth Eelam wars, to the ending of hostilities in 2009. War in Paradise is less a story about victory than a warning about possible repetition. Its most haunting argument is that Sri Lanka defeated an enemy but did not dismantle the thinking of 'othering' that had made the opponent have a cause in the first place. Given that these are comparatively recent events which are still etched in my mind, where I too celebrated the ending of terrorism that I've known from my childhood, where parents of childhood friends, and my relations lost their lives, I will dwell more on the post-2009 disappointments, which trouble me to date. The series ends not simply with the military defeat of the LTTE in 2009, but with the uncomfortable question of whether Sri Lanka learned anything from the war. The documentary’s wider stated purpose is to encourage reflection on the past so violence is not repeated. Instead of building a shared Sri Lankan identity, the country continued to organize political belonging around ethnicity, religion, and suspicion of the “other.” As I write this there is a big opposition for the newly proposed PSTA bill tabled in the parliament, as an alternative for the PTA act, which this government has vouched to repeal. Teardrop Nation ends in 2009, but its relevance extends into the present. The promised repeal of the PTA was meant to signal that Sri Lanka had learned the cost of governing through fear. Yet the proposed PSTA suggests that the state may be replacing an old system of suppression with a new one. If the war taught Sri Lanka anything, it should have been that security cannot be built by criminalizing difference, silencing dissent, or treating particular communities as permanently suspect. On the other hand certain religious sections that fueled discontent among the ethnicities still continue to spread discord among the public. So what exactly have we learned and what hope do we have ?
*Personally I have often wondered if an N.M. Perera and early LSSP were able to establish the first government, against whatever odds they had, whether we'd be in a different place today. Their programme opposed inequalities based on race, caste, creed and sex. It advocated using both Sinhala and Tamil in courts, police stations and, progressively, government departments. Its political programme also emphasised workers’ protections and social welfare.

